Mayoral Debate… and The Winner Is….
This is a performance critique on debate number one.
There was no clear winner in the first Mayoral Debate, but there were some interesting moments. Despite the elitist critics who decry his genuine nature, Bob Brady had the best night, showing a sense of connection with the viewer. Brady speaks to Philadelphia. As a broadcaster, I can tell you that he was the “connector” in this debate. His jab at Knox to stop beating up on the other candidates was the moment of the night. Brady will gain votes.
The big surprise was Chaka Fattah. The real pro in terms of experience, has had a hard time finding his voice in this campaign. He needs to look more leader-like, more down to earth. The passion within him has yet to damatically surface. Also, his support for a new trial for cop klller Mumia Abu-Jamal is hurting him citywide. Fattah needs to look like a Mayor. The man has been a leader for a long time. He needs to assert himself. And he needs to distance himself from the Mumia movement.
Tom Knox made the most news by forgiving his 5 million dollar loan, therefore insisting that he alone is paying for this campaign. Away from the protection iof 30 second commercials, Knox looked uneasy but he got into a flow at the end of the progtam. Knox kept clearing his throat. Maybe he needs a rest. Knox , who is a good one on one talker, needs to bring that to TV.
Dwight Evans was his usual brilliant self but Evans needs to speak less as a stump speaker and more on a one to one basis with people. Evans knowledge is a pleasure to watch. but this amazing policy expert needs to put his passion on display. Someone has told him to back off. He needs to show his strength – his love for politics and government.
Michael Nutter had the best information and accomplished what he needed to — a succint address on the independent issues that separate him from the rest — war on ethics, lower taxes etc. Nutter was strong and earnest. He helped himself. Nutter is a straightforward guy and it came across.
Bottom line: Good TV from Brady and Nutter. Decent performances from the others.
Channel 3 did a great job. Larry Mendte kept them all on time. That, in itself, is a miracle.
